How to Choose a Residential Painting Company in New Jersey
So you’ve finally decided it’s time to give your house a fresh coat of paint — maybe the siding’s looking tired, or you’re just over that off-white in the living room. Either way, the search begins: “residential painting company near me in New Jersey.”
Now you’re staring at 10 different websites, all promising the same thing: “fast,” “affordable,” “professional.”
But how do you know which one to trust with your biggest investment — your home?
At Quick Sidekick, we’ve been called in after other painting jobs went sideways, so we know what to look out for. In this guide, we’ll show you how to choose the right painting contractor in NJ — and what red flags to avoid.
Why Choosing the Right Painting Company Matters
You might think paint is paint — but the truth is, the difference between a great job and a terrible one often comes down to who you hire.
A good residential painting company:
Preps the surface properly
Uses the right paint and finish
Applies even coats with no drips or streaks
Finishes on time, on budget
Leaves your home clean, not chaotic
On the flip side, a bad contractor can leave you with:
Peeling paint in a few months
Uneven coverage and missed spots
Damaged siding or interior surfaces
Hidden fees or poor communication
If you’re investing money into improving your home’s appearance and value, make sure it’s done once and done right.
Step 1: Look for Experience in Residential Projects
There’s a big difference between painting a warehouse and painting your dining room or vinyl siding. Look for painters with specific experience in residential jobs, especially in the New Jersey climate.
Ask questions like:
“How many homes have you painted in NJ?”
“Do you do both interior and exterior work?”
“Are you familiar with painting stucco, vinyl, or wood siding?”
At Quick Sidekick, we specialize in residential painting projects — from Ridgefield to Weehawken, we know the weather, the building styles, and the materials.
Step 2: Ask What’s Included in the Service
Not all painting services are created equal. A trustworthy company will offer complete solutions, not just a brush-and-go job.
Here’s what should be included:
Surface prep (patching holes, sanding, caulking)
Priming (especially over dark colors or stains)
Two coats minimum
Protection of your furniture, floors, or landscaping
Cleanup and final inspection
Need additional help prepping your walls or trim? Our handyman team can take care of repairs before painting begins.
Step 3: Check Their Portfolio and Reviews
Before you let anyone near your walls with a roller, check their:
Before-and-after photos
Online reviews (Google, Yelp, Facebook)
References from recent clients
A solid residential painting company won’t just tell you they’re good — they’ll show you.
Want to see our work? Visit our project portfolio for real examples of what Quick Sidekick has done in homes like yours.
Step 4: Understand the Paint They Use
A high-quality painting contractor will never skimp on materials.
Ask:
“What brand of paint do you use?”
“Will you apply a primer?”
“Do you offer low-VOC or eco-friendly options?”
We use premium brands like Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams and tailor the finish (matte, eggshell, satin, etc.) to the room’s needs and traffic level.
Step 5: Ask About Timelines and Communication
We’ve heard horror stories of painters starting and then disappearing for a week, or dragging out a “two-day job” for two weeks.
At Quick Sidekick, we:
Stick to a clear schedule
Keep you updated daily
Arrive on time
Respect your space
📞 Need to get your project done before a move-in date or family event? Let us know — we’ll build a timeline that works for you.
🛠️ Step 6: Ask About Other Services You Can Bundle
Many homeowners forget that a painting job often overlaps with:
Drywall repairs
Trim or molding updates
Gutter or roof cleaning (especially for exterior jobs)
Deck and fence staining
We offer exterior painting and cleaning services that can be bundled to save you time and money. One crew, one visit, multiple upgrades. Call Now